After 11 hours of research among 30 recognized models on the market, we believe that the best option is the Microsoft Xbox One (V3) .
Microsoft Xbox One (V3)
This controller is a reference in ergonomics. It not
only has a good quality of finish but also responsive keys and efficient enough
to guarantee its reliability with any type of game.
It retains the appreciable properties of the 360 such
as ergonomics and playing comfort. It brings, in addition, improvements such as
the new more practical directional cross or the vibrating triggers for a good
dose of immersion. The latest version brings Bluetooth connectivity and an even
more refined grip thanks to a better grip and fully activated slice keys.
8Bitdo SN30 Pro (wired)
With a design that will make you nostalgic for the 90s,
this gaming accessory is lightweight and compatible with different platforms.
As a bonus, it modernizes a recognized format by adding current features.
The most attractive about the 8BitDo SN30 Pro is its
flat design, worthy of the 90s. Compared to previous decades, this one has been
modernized with the appearance of joysticks and extended compatibility. Too bad
the ergonomics are tarnished by the lack of handles. A wireless version is also
available for those allergic to cables.
Microsoft Xbox Elite Series 2
Take a benchmark controller and add some deep
customization to it to get this model. Intended for experienced players, it
pushes the optimization further for maximum comfort, regardless of the duration
of use.
The Xbox Elite Series 2 is a very sophisticated
controller, especially thanks to its interchangeable buttons. As a bonus, you
can create your own profiles via the dedicated application to configure the
sensitivity of the different components. Just like the model on which it is
based, the Series 2 always gives you comfort and support, being even better
than the previous version.
Logitech F310
The only wired controller in our ranking, it is intended
to be versatile while being pleasant to use. This is a very good introduction
for those who want to equip themselves at a low price.
With a light weight and a good grip, this controller is
quite ergonomic. It comes in a small format at a democratic price. After an
automatic configuration, you will enjoy many games, recent or older, thanks to
its wide compatibility. It is unfortunately not at the level of our best cheap
model because of the absence of vibrations, its thread and its perfectible
quality of finish.
Sony DualShock 4 v2
Evolution of the famous Dualshock, this version benefits
from reworked ergonomics, extended connectivity and good build quality. As a
bonus, its lack of latency guarantees high responsiveness, no matter the game.
Although it seems less efficient than its competitor,
the second version of the DualShock 4 still sets the bar very high. Lightweight
and built with good materials, it conforms to the shape of the hand and offers
good grip. However, its autonomy is a little too weak to really take advantage
of wireless.
Nacon Revolution Unlimited Pro
This controller combines precision and customization
with additional keys configurable via the dedicated software. Its comfort is
added to its other qualities which make it a model worthy of experienced
players.
Designed in collaboration with esports professionals,
this controller is certified by Sony as an official model. It is not only
pleasant to use but also precise and fully configurable. Despite some minor
flaws, such as its battery life and unusual handling, it presents a good
alternative for PC gamers who also have a Sony console.
Why trust us ?
None of our articles are sponsored. We sometimes receive
a commission when you purchase a product through our links, which allows us to
fund our work while remaining completely impartial. Learn more .
How did we make our choice?
The search for the perfect playmate is not an easy thing
and we often find ourselves hesitating between recognized models and affordable
products of a more obscure origin.
To help you find a choice that meets your budget, we
have determined the following criteria:
Ergonomics: so that you get the most out of your gaming
sessions without having to stop because of hand pain, it is important to dwell
on this point. The grip must be natural without requiring improbable positions
of your fingers to be effective. In this sense, the placement of the buttons
and the size of the controller also have their impact. We strongly advise you
to bet on this point rather than an interesting design.
Integrated controls: directly linked to ergonomics, this
criterion represents the number of buttons available, their responsiveness and
their size. Ancillary functions are also important. Thus, if the majority of
controllers have joysticks , some do not. Others incorporate a gyroscope and an
accelerometer for motion capture, a turbo function or even vibrating triggers.
Determine what your needs are before making your choice, and always think about
your intended use.
Connectivity and compatibility : wired or wireless, a
controller must be connected to a device. It must of course be compatible with
your controller so that you can enjoy it in your games. The best solution in
our eyes is Bluetooth for its versatility. However, on the other hand, the
latency is slightly higher than with a radio signal or a cable. The models we
offer are all compatible with Windows and some add console, MacOS and sometimes
even Android compatibility.
Build quality and design : these are more important for
the durability of your device, especially if you want to transport it
regularly. Logically, the more you go upmarket, the more the overall quality is
felt ... even if we can sometimes be positively surprised by the entry level.
On the design side, it's all about taste. Generally, the choice of color is the
only criterion independent of the model.
In the end, on the basis of these criteria, we were able
to reduce our list to around ten products. Reading numerous tests and user
reviews, both French and English, allowed us to compose our selection with the
6 products that are offered in this article.
Microsoft Xbox One (V3)
This controller is a reference in ergonomics. It not
only has a good quality of finish but also responsive keys and efficient enough
to guarantee its reliability with any type of game.
This controller retains the advantages of the 360 by
bringing improvements such as the new directional cross, more practical, or the
vibrating triggers. As a bonus, the latest version brings Bluetooth
connectivity and an even more refined handling thanks to a better grip and
fully activated slice keys.
Its ergonomics, precisely, is considered by many as a
benchmark in the field. Its asymmetrical design allows efficient use of all the
keys without risking your fingers knocking.
Thus, the diameter of the joysticks has been reduced to
promote use with the fingertips, reinforced by their concave shape. The size of
the edge keys has been increased in order to allow a more varied grip. In
addition, V3 makes the LB and RB keys fully clickable.
The grip in itself is also optimized: the handles fit
well in the palm, a non-slip surface is present on the back of the device and
on the top of the sticks.
In terms of functions, we find the traditional buttons,
nothing atypical at this level with the exception of the LT and RT triggers
which have their own vibration system, ideal for immersion. The quality is
still there with a good precision of the sticks and the clickable directional
cross, well damped and sufficiently resistant triggers and keys with the
correct rebound.
The controller can be connected in 3 ways: via the USB
cable (which also allows the connection of a live headset), via Bluetooth or
via the radio signal (for Xbox or via a dedicated dongle for PC ). It is
compatible with Windows and the various Xboxes. Some users mention the
possibility of connecting with other devices using bluetooth (but there is no
official confirmation in this regard).
On the design and quality side, we are faced with a
product worthy of Microsoft, with neat finishes and a choice of materials
accordingly. It is available in many colors and, if you wish, Microsoft
provides you with a space on its site to fully customize it to your tastes . Be
careful, the price of course evolves accordingly.
In the end, this controller is a reference in
ergonomics. It not only has a good quality of finish but also responsive keys
and efficient enough to guarantee its reliability with any type of game.
8Bitdo SN30 Pro (wired)
With a design that will make you nostalgic for the 90s,
this gaming accessory is lightweight and compatible with different platforms.
As a bonus, it modernizes a recognized format by adding current features.
The most attractive about the 8BitDo SN30 Pro is its
flat design, worthy of the 90s. Compared to previous decades, this one has been
modernized with the appearance of joysticks and extended compatibility. Too bad
the ergonomics are tarnished by the lack of handles. A wireless version is also
available.
If you're riding the retrogaming wave or using a
Nintendo Switch, you've surely heard of this builder. It takes the design of
the vintage controllers after having slightly adapted it.
As a result, the feeling when using the SN30 Pro is
quite authentic and it is easy to believe that an official model is used as the
quality is present. The only difference at this level comes from its thickness,
which is slightly higher. She is therefore a little less suitable for small
hands than her grandmother.
The modernization of the whole also required an
adaptation of the positioning of the keys. Thus, in addition to the usual
controls, you will find: 2 joysticks, 2 additional slice buttons and 2 buttons
on the lower part of the front panel (star and home). These buttons are a very
handy addition to all current games and their variety of shortcuts. However,
FPS / TPS enthusiasts will be a little disappointed because the lack of grips
does not promote good use of joysticks. The SN30 Pro + corrects this problem,
however.
Overall, the feeling is, once again, close to the
original model: thick, dry and responsive buttons and a precise directional
cross even if it is a little rigid. It is also ideal for platform games. The
set also includes a gyroscope and an accelerometer.
You can use Bluetooth or the supplied USB-C cable for
the connection. In wireless mode, its battery life is approximately 15 hours.
The wired version connects via USB. It is compatible
with Windows (7 or higher), Nintendo Switch, Steam and Raspberry Pi. The
wireless version adds support for D-Input (Android and old Windows games) and
MacOS.
The latter is available in 3 colors, one in reference to
the European SNES, one to the US version and even one to the first Gameboy !
Microsoft Xbox Elite Series 2
Take a benchmark controller and add some deep customization
to it to get this model. Intended for experienced players, it pushes the
optimization further for maximum comfort, regardless of the duration of use.
The Xbox Elite Series 2 is a very sophisticated
controller, in particular thanks to its interchangeable buttons. As a bonus,
you can create your own profiles via the dedicated application to configure the
sensitivity of the different elements, for example. Just like the model on
which it is based, the Series 2 always gives you comfort and support, being
even better than its previous version.
Its format is also relatively similar. You can always
customize the buttons using the different sticks provided. On the other hand,
the Series 2 is heavier with a weight of 345 g, but this is a classic
characteristic of more sophisticated models. This controller is made from
soft-touch plastic and luxurious materials that provide a comfortable grip for
long gaming sessions.
At the level of the keys, nothing unusual except the
presence of 4 triggers on the bottom of the controller. They can be assigned to
an action via the dedicated program.
The biggest visual change comes instead from the new
directional cross which presents a design at the very least original with an
unusual shape replacing the traditional format. Fans of precision have the
option of replacing it with a more classic model, supplied with the controller.
Other customization possibilities are available to you:
the triggers located on the bottom of the controller are removable and 4
alternative sticks are provided. Their resistance is also adjustable using a
key.
All these keys can be configured via the “Xbox
Accessories” application (Windows 10), which is easy to use. It offers many
features to put the gamer in the best possible conditions thanks, in
particular, to the 3 programmable profiles. However, if you want to have access
to this app, you will need a Windows account.
Like the others, it can be connected in wired mode with
a long 2.7 m cable or with Bluetooth. The Wi-Fi Direct mode is also available
which makes it compatible with the future console of the brand, the Series X.
In wireless, its autonomy is 40 hours, a very good result when compared to the
competition . Note, however, that the battery cannot be removed.
In the end, the Xbox Elite Series 2 is the ultimate
controller for performance and optimization enthusiasts.
Logitech F310
The only wired controller in our ranking, it is intended
to be versatile while being pleasant to use. This is a very good introduction
for those who want to equip themselves at a low price.
With a light weight and a good grip, this controller is
quite ergonomic. It comes in a small format at a democratic price. After an
automatic configuration, you will enjoy many games, recent or older, thanks to
its wide compatibility. It is unfortunately not at the level of our best cheap
model because of the absence of vibrations and its thread.
Let's start first with its ergonomics, clearly inspired
by the Sony Dualshock 3. It is light and pleasant to use and will not disturb
the majority of users too much. However, it has the same flaw as the latter:
when the joysticks are both oriented towards the center, the fingertips can
collide which can be quite uncomfortable, especially for large hands.
At the level of the keys, the observation is the same,
the usual keys are present but badged, this time, according to those of
Microsoft (ABXY). The only peculiarity that deserves to be mentioned is the
4-way directional cross which is very precise and which will delight lovers of
platform games. On the other hand, no integrated vibration system. If it is
essential for you, we invite you to upgrade to the next model, the F710 which,
as a bonus, has wireless connectivity.
For connectivity, you are entitled to Windows (D-Input
and X-Input), MacOS, Linux and Android TV. The controller is plug & play
and works with a good library of games. For older people who do not support
joysticks, you have a button to reverse directional cross and left joystick to
still enjoy this additional comfort.
The concessions were especially made on the choice of
materials: the feeling of robustness is weak because of the plastic coating and
the lightness of the whole. In addition, several users note a certain fragility
of the joysticks.
Sony DualShock 4 v2
Evolution of the famous Dualshock, this version benefits
from reworked ergonomics, extended connectivity and good build quality. As a
bonus, its lack of latency guarantees high responsiveness, no matter the game.
Although it seems less efficient than its competitor,
the second version of the DualShock 4 still sets the bar very high. Lightweight
and built with good materials, it conforms to the shape of the hand and offers
good grip. However, its autonomy is a little too weak to really take advantage
of wireless.
Lighter (218 g) and compact than the Xbox controller, it
is however less ergonomic because of its less worked form and its symmetrical
organization, less efficient. It will not disturb those used to the brand's
controllers because the feeling remains similar. It also corrects the defect of
the previous version which could cause some discomfort to large hands.
Its performance is based around its 8 action buttons,
the touchpad and its 2 concave joysticks, which incidentally benefit from a
material different from the first version to deteriorate less quickly. The
directional cross is quite precise and flexible for skill games. On the other
hand, the triggers, although sufficiently precise, are a little difficult to
access because they are quite small.
Its plastic design promises a relatively soft touch that
allows a good grip, although it is a little less comfortable than the Xbox. It
also has a built-in speaker as well as an audio input and output (the sound
quality of which leaves a little to be desired).
Two options are available to you in terms of
connectivity with either wireless or wired. But for the latter, know that the
cable is not supplied with. The wireless connection with the console has been
optimized to its maximum to offer minimum latency (close to wired), despite the
use of Bluetooth. It also displays Windows, Mac and mobile compatibility.
Its big weak point is its autonomy. With only 6 to 8
hours of resistance, it is far from its competitor, which is five times more
efficient at this level.
It exists in no less than 13 colors and new ones are
added regularly. The build quality is up from the first version with a new
choice of material for the joysticks.
In the end, this evolution of the famous Dualshock
benefits from reworked ergonomics, extended connectivity and good build
quality. As a bonus, its lack of latency guarantees high responsiveness, no
matter the game.
Nacon Revolution Unlimited Pro
This controller combines precision and customization
with additional keys configurable via the dedicated software. Its comfort is
added to its other qualities which make it a model worthy of experienced
players.
Designed in collaboration with esports professionals,
this controller is certified by Sony as an official model. It is not only
pleasant to use but also precise and fully configurable. Despite some minor
flaws, such as its battery life and unusual handling, it presents a good
alternative for PC gamers who also have a Sony console.
Its 224 g give it the lightness necessary for good
comfort and the arrangement of the elements of the controller has been designed
to facilitate the task and the access to the players. Pleasant to handle and
soft to the touch, it opts for an asymmetrical layout, much more ergonomic. The
sticks have a non-slip coating which is still slightly slippery in use.
The set of keys is sensitive and precise while the
analog triggers are adjustable. On the other hand, the size of the Share and
Options buttons is a bit small, as is the touchpad. However, their use is
secondary.
And since we are on a “Pro” controller, we are entitled
to four additional buttons (M1 to M4), which are integrated into the handles.
Their use takes time to adapt, but they are very useful once you get used to
them.
Connectivity level, you have the choice between a mode
with a 3 m long cable or wireless using the dongle provided. The latter uses
Bluetooth but further optimizes the connection with the device by halving the
latency compared to a classic dualshock controller.
It binds to the PS4 or to a Windows PC. The dedicated
program allows the creation of four profiles that can be used via Advanced
mode. Nacon pushes the customization even further by providing weights to weigh
down the controller, interchangeable joystick heads (convex or concave) and
different bases for the sticks to adjust the activation amplitude (30 °, 38 °
(PS4 standard ) and 48 ° (PS3)).
In the end, the Nacon Revolution Pro is a competitor to
be reckoned with, even if Microsoft continues to dominate.
Honorable mentions
SteelSeries Stratus Duo (€ 79.94 at publication): With a
sober design, this controller offers a pleasant gaming experience thanks to its
efficient and precise triggers. Its correct weight makes it comfortable to
hold. In Bluetooth mode, its battery has a respectable autonomy of 20 hours.
Unfortunately, although it is compatible with Windows and Android, we must be
wary of iOS, where it does not work with all games.
Valve Steam Controller (€ 129.90 at publication): The
Steam Controller is a different controller. For her, no directional pad or
second joystick but rather a duo of touchpads. They allow it a very high
precision while giving it access to features hitherto unusable with a
controller. You can adapt it according to your needs thanks to the settings
present in its dedicated application. It is designed to work with Windows,
MacOS, Linux and Android.
0 Comments